Petaluma
Coonawarra Vertical Tasting
Website: http://www.petaluma.com.au/
Coonawarra is one of Australia's great
distinguished vineyard sites. The key to its success is the soil -
terra rossa over limestone - and the relatively cool climate.
Although it is reasonably far inland, there is still some maritime
influence which tempers what would otherwise be a warm location.
There's something distinctive about Coonawarra reds.
Indeed, this is a place where Cabernet Sauvignon really succeeds:
elsewhere in Australia, it struggles a bit, with perhaps the
exception of the Margaret River.
Brian
Croser's vision in setting up Petaluma was quite before its time:
in Australia, most wineries do a bit of everything, making a wide
portfolio of varietal wines from the same property. Croser set out
to identify special sites, and with Petaluma he had Chardonnay
from the Adelaide Hills, Riesling from the Clare and for his
Bordeaux blend, labelled simply Coonawarra, he took advantage of
the fact that Coonawarra makes great Cabernet Sauvignon and
Merlot.
This
vertical tasting, with Brian and leading French critic Michel
Bettane at the winery in the Adelaide Hills, was an eye-opener.
I'd always thought this wine was good; I don't think I'd
previously realized how good, and how consistently good. I reckon
this is one of Australia's great wines, and at a penny under £20
in the UK, it's tremendously good value.
The inaugural 1979 was 60% Shiraz, 40% Cabernet – the
last vintage to contain any Shiraz in it was 1982, with 12%. Since
then it has been either a varietal Cabernet Sauvignon, or more
commonly a blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot.
Petaluma Coonawarra 1982
Evolved open nose is savoury and earthy with some fruit
sweetness. The palate is quite aged and is on a downward curve.
Nice weight and balance to this rather Clarety red that is good
current drinking but shouldn’t be kept much longer. Savoury, dry
finish. Very good+ 86/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1986
Rich, spicy, full nose with a tarry, smoky overlay. Warm woody
character, too. The palate is full, fresh and minty with a savoury
spiciness. Finishes very dry. Very good+ 88/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1988
According to Brian Croser, this is the first year when the
Merlot in the vineyard had settled down and was behaving properly.
Interesting savoury, slightly tarry nose with a nice leafy edge
and some minerality. The palate shows lovely concentration and
weight, with nice balance. There’s real Coonawarra character
here. Fresh and savoury. Lovely. Very good/excellent 93/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1990
Ripe, sweet, expressive berry fruits nose that’s currently
in great balance. The palate shows nice weight and balance, too:
it’s savoury, slightly minerally and a bit leafy with good
structure and acidity and a minerally finish. Delicious stuff,
showing that just a little bit of greenness can be a good thing in
some wine styles. Very good/excellent 93/100
Petaluma
Coonawarra 1991
100% Cabernet Sauvignon from a hot year when the Merlot was no
good. Quite a ripe, sweet berry fruit nose with lots of warmth and
a savoury edge. The palate is quite structured and dense with more
savouriness. Finishes a little short but there’s still life in
this wine. Very good/excellent 90/100
Petaluma
Coonawarra 1992
Really lovely classic Coonawarra nose of open dark fruits with
a leafy, chalky edge. Delicious, savoury and elegant on the
palate: the dense, spicy structure is perfectly meshed with the
fruit. Very good/excellent 93/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1995
Picked by Easter, this was a small crop, and was one of the
best years for this wine. Dark, dense colour. Tight, restrained
nose with lots of elegance, and a rich, savoury tarry edge to the
fruit. Big but very well balanced. The palate is structured and
brooding, but with it elegant. This needs time still. A fantastic
effort. Excellent 95/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1996
A big crop at 7 tons/hectare (~45 hl/ha). Sweet, slightly
minty tarry edge to the ripe fruit. Sweet and accessible. Nice
weight on the palate which combines sweet fruit and good
structure. Not the most complex vintage, but still quite lovely.
Very good/excellent 90/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 1998
Youthful, tight, tarry dark fruits nose with brooding spicy
minerally notes. Ripe and full, in a dark, rich style. The palate
is hugely concentrated, showing rich dark fruits backed up by
spicy tannic structure. Big but beautiful. Very good/excellent
94/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 2000
This was a short crop and they picked everything they had out
of necessity. A dark wine, this is sweet and smooth on the nose.
Quite elegant actually, with a chocolatey richness. The palate is
quite dense with expressive dark fruits. Fantastic fruit and a
lovely structure: another brilliant effort. Excellent 95/100
Petaluma Coonawarra 2001
Another short crop. Lovely dark fruits nose: rich, tight and
intense with some nice cedary, tarry oak overlay. The palate is
expressive and shows lovely definition of fruit. It is ripe with
super balance and nice structure. Just a hint of minty herbiness
on the finish. Lots of structure and potential. Very
good/excellent 94/100
Wines tasted 10/05
Find
these wines with wine-searcher.com
see also: Brian
Croser, Petaluma and Tapanappa Part 1, and Part
3
See
also: A review (2010) of the
wines of Tapanappa
Back
to top
|